Trump Envoys’ ‘Ludicrous’ Russia Blunder Stuns Expert

Two of President Donald Trump’s envoys let a Russian government vehicle drive them to their meeting with Vladimir Putin, and a retired Army general says that one choice may have handed Moscow the contents of their phones.

Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner traveled to Russia on Saturday, Sept. 5, to meet Putin about ending the war in Ukraine. Reports say a Russian government car carried the two men to the meeting. Retired Army Maj. Gen. Randy Manner called that a “ludicrous” mistake on CNN’s “OutFront” with Erin Burnett.

Video: Frontline via YouTube

Everything on the phone, copied without a trace

Manner’s worry was not about protocol. It was about what sits inside a modern car. “It’s important for your listeners to understand that the Russians have the ability that, if you get within a certain number of feet of a device that would be included in that vehicle, they can take everything off of your phone and copy it without you even knowing it,” he said. Contacts, messages, emails, all of it, he warned, could then belong to the Russians.

He did not soften the point. Accepting a Russian vehicle, Manner said, showed “the ignorance and lack of knowledge in general about how sophisticated the Russians are.” He called the whole thing a “ludicrous, unbelievable situation.”

More than three hours inside the Kremlin

The meeting ran long. Witkoff and Kushner spent more than three hours with Putin at the Kremlin on Sept. 5, leaving around 11 p.m. local time. Before that, they had a business lunch at a Moscow restaurant with Russian presidential envoy Kirill Dmitriev that reportedly lasted about 3.5 hours. Dmitriev greeted them on X by writing, “Welcome to Moscow, peacemakers Witkoff and Kushner.”

Putin opened by calling the situation “not easy” and asked the two men to pass along his gratitude to Trump. Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov later described the conversation as “substantive, constructive, extremely frank and trustworthy,” and said the Americans had put forward a number of ideas on possible routes to a settlement. A White House official said the two sides discussed “substantive plans for next steps, which will be announced in the coming weeks.” Putin told the envoys he still expects Russia to meet its goals. Moscow has said it wants to occupy the rest of Ukrainian-controlled Donetsk Oblast and treats Ukraine’s NATO ambitions as a threat.

Witkoff’s toast to Putin

What Witkoff said inside the room drew as much heat as how he got there. Sitting across from Putin, he talked about the memories the negotiators would carry. “When we retire, we’ll have all these incredible stories and incredible memories, and yours will be right at the top of it all,” he told the Russian leader, according to the Kremlin’s own transcript.

Putin returned the warmth, telling the pair he finds it comfortable to work with them and that there is a high level of trust in the room. Witkoff also thanked Putin for endorsing the “no shoot policy” in Kyiv and Moscow during the visit, and for the release of Robert Gilman, a 32-year-old U.S. Marine veteran and teacher who had been imprisoned in Russia since 2022 and was freed last month. Putin replied that the Gilman family should be thanking Trump, “it was he who made the appeal.”

‘I was actually pretty disgusted’

CNN national security analyst Alex Plitsas, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, tore into the trip on “The Lead.” “I was actually pretty disgusted with what I heard,” he said. “It’s the first time I’ve used that type of language to describe this, but this was embarrassing.”

Plitsas said the sound bites out of Moscow and Kyiv were “nothing short of embarrassing for the United States and were absolutely abhorrent.” He zeroed in on Kushner’s suggestion that Putin’s “aspirations” for his country could be met once the war ends. Giving in to those aspirations, Plitsas said, “is absurd.” He noted that Putin’s troops “have killed hundreds of thousands across Ukraine,” with documented war crimes, and that the Russian leader wants “to take the rest of the country.”

Plitsas allowed that a real peace deal might require “some territorial swaps.” His problem was the language. Kushner had described the effort in Kyiv as a possible “win-win” for both countries, and Plitsas said talk of fond memories in Moscow, paired with the idea that Putin’s aspirations should be honored, was simply absurd.

‘You don’t send Kushner and Witkoff’

The choice of these two envoys drew its own criticism. On a CNN panel hosted by Audie Cornish, former U.S. Army major Harrison Mann, once an executive officer at the Defense Intelligence Agency, questioned whether the trip was ever built to produce a deal. “I think it’s worth recognizing that you don’t send Kushner and Witkoff when you actually really want to get something done,” he said, pointing to their record on Iran and Gaza.

Mann tied the frozen state of the talks to a bigger event. Negotiations had been suspended for six months, and he blamed the war the United States started in Iran. “Trump started this big war in Iran,” he said. “And that’s probably the biggest effect that has weakened the negotiating position of Ukraine and the pro-Ukraine alliance.” He also described a constant arms race on the battlefield, with each side learning from the other, and said Russia may now have AI-guided drones that can beat the jamming networks Ukraine has built.

A truce that didn’t outlast the week

Putin ordered a 72-hour pause in strikes on Kyiv starting at midnight on Sept. 5 to line up with the visit. “Putin has ordered that no strikes be carried out against Kyiv for three days, starting at midnight today,” Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said, according to Russian state media. Zelensky said Ukraine would hold off on strikes against Moscow through Monday. Ukraine had asked for a wider, three-day truce that covered the front line as well, but Putin said Russia never agreed to it.

The quiet did not last. After the envoys left, Russia resumed airstrikes early Tuesday, killing five people and injuring about 35. Plitsas read the broken truce as a message: Putin “still thinks that he can win this war and he’s told his army to double down.” That came, he said, after CIA Director John Ratcliffe visited Moscow at Trump’s request to deliver a stern warning, which Russia apparently read “as a sign of weakness.”

Even the days around the talks were violent. In one overnight wave, Ukraine’s air force said Russia launched ballistic missiles and 167 attack drones, hitting airports in Kyiv and Boryspil and killing five people at an industrial site elsewhere in the country. During the very day the envoys sat with Putin, at least three people were killed and more than 20 injured in Russian drone attacks.

Two developers with a diplomatic track record

Witkoff and Kushner are both real estate developers Trump has leaned on for high-level talks. Kushner, the president’s son-in-law, served as a senior adviser in Trump’s first term and now runs the investment firm Affinity Partners. The weekend marked their first trip to Kyiv since Russia’s full-scale invasion.

Trump sent them off with praise. “We have an idea for peace,” he told reporters on Friday. “I sent Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, two great negotiators. They’ve done a great job, and we sent them over to see whether or not we can get something done. And there may be a good chance that we’ll do it.” The pair met Putin for five hours in December 2025 in talks a Russian official called constructive, though nothing broke loose, and returned to Moscow in January. Trump had met Putin himself in Anchorage, Alaska, in August 2025 and left empty-handed, and a planned Budapest summit that October was canceled days after it was announced. “It just didn’t feel right to me,” Trump said at the time.

What they say they came home with

In Kyiv on Sunday, the envoys pushed to restart three-way talks between the United States, Russia and Ukraine. Zelensky said several new ideas were discussed but did not lay them out. Witkoff and Kushner described the weekend’s talks as “encouraging.”

The visit landed in the middle of a grinding war that began with Russia’s full-scale invasion on Feb. 24, 2022. Days before the envoys arrived, a Russian drone hit the headquarters of Ukraine’s SBU security service in central Kyiv, the first strike on that building since the invasion. Over one 24-hour stretch around the trip, Russian attacks killed at least seven people and injured at least 51. Earlier peace attempts had stalled for months, and this one ended the same way many others have, with the missiles falling again as soon as the visitors were gone.

Jordan Hale
Jordan Hale
Jordan Hale is a senior editor and staff writer covering national headlines, politics, business, and culture. He focuses on clear, fact-based reporting and timely coverage of stories shaping the United States. His work emphasizes accuracy, context, and straightforward reporting for a broad national audience.

Related Articles

Latest

FBI Warns Grocers as Hackers Heat Store Freezers to 122 Degrees

Five federal agencies issued one warning on Nov. 5, and grocery stores are not the only target.

London Jury Convicts Russell Brand of Rape and Sexual Assault

He had one thing to tell his lawyers as officers led him from the courtroom.

FBI Arrests Meghan Markle’s Father Thomas Markle in Florida

Agents walked into a Florida care home. Investigators in three countries are now on the case.

LaKesha Womack Unseats Tim Moore With Felony Car Case Pending

A first-time candidate toppled a political heavyweight. A week later, on Nov. 10, she is due in a Charlotte courtroom.

Newsletter

Don't miss

Car Veers Off Interstate 5 Into San Diego Backyard

Something left the southbound 5 Wednesday morning and did not stop at the shoulder.

Megyn Kelly Declares Republican Party in Ruins After Democratic Sweep

Years of loyalty ended on her show the morning after the votes came in.

Five Rescued Off Kiribati After Drifting 3,355 Miles at Sea

A one-hour boat ride in July ended on a coral atoll in November.

Nicole Taylor of Country Trio Taylor Red Dies at 35

Her sisters waited more than a month before telling fans what happened.

Rachel Apa, 24, Dies After Collapsing at Mile 24 of NYC Marathon

Her father tracked every mile from Pennsylvania. Then the texts stopped coming.