Matthew Ammel, the former bodyguard and ex-boyfriend of former Arizona Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, is back in a Maricopa County jail after detectives say his court-ordered GPS tracker placed him at a gun shop in north Phoenix, where he had left a large hunting-style knife to be engraved.
Ammel, 39, was out on pretrial release in a felony criminal damage case tied to Sinema’s Cave Creek home. The conditions of that release barred him from possessing a knife and ordered him to stay away from Sinema, 50.
Prosecutors with the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office filed an emergency motion asking a judge to raise his bond to $100,000 cash-only, telling the court Ammel had threatened to “take her down” and that he poses an escalating danger to Sinema and to the public.
They took him in a Cheesecake Factory parking lot
Detectives with the Arizona State Gang Task Force coaxed Ammel out of his hotel room near 24th Street and Camelback Road and asked him to walk across the street, according to court records. He was taken into custody at 9:45 p.m. on Tuesday, Sept. 29, in the parking lot of The Cheesecake Factory. There was no struggle.
The knife was still sitting at the store. When a sheriff’s detective contacted the owner, the owner said Ammel had asked to have a large hunting-style knife engraved. Ammel did not deny having what officials described as a “large, military-style knife.” He said he wanted the engraving done as a gift for his nephew’s Marine Corps boot camp graduation.
Prosecutors say the knife was the smallest part of it
The state’s filing describes Ammel as a “highly trained military soldier” who “contacted military friends to build him a rifle, purchased tactical gear, and discussed funeral arrangements.”
“The state fears defendant will escalate his retaliation if released,” Deputy County Attorney Bryn Barasha wrote in the motion.
Court filings say Ammel made threats against the lives of sitting judges, lawyers and police personnel. Prosecutors wrote that officers have serious safety concerns because of his “erratic” behavior, his “highly skilled” military training, and his effort to get “military friends” to help him assemble a rifle.
A North Carolina lieutenant called Arizona first
Hours before the GPS hit at the gun shop, Arizona pretrial officials received a warning from a sheriff’s lieutenant in North Carolina. The lieutenant said Ammel was trying to acquire guns and tactical equipment and had threatened to kill a judge in that state, according to investigators.
Ammel is already serving unsupervised probation for an earlier felony case in North Carolina.
Prosecutors say he also broke the protective order not long after his earlier release by asking a mutual acquaintance to contact Sinema on his behalf.
He refused to leave the jail for his own hearing
A judge set bond at $25,000 on the morning of Sept. 30 and said the previous release conditions would apply again if Ammel got out. That same afternoon, the county attorney’s office came back asking for $100,000 cash-only.
Ammel was due in Maricopa County Superior Court on Oct. 1 to be arraigned. He refused to be transported. The judge moved the arraignment to Oct. 15 and ordered that Ammel be brought to court by any means necessary, including force, over an objection from his attorney.
22 paintings in the swimming pool
The criminal case dates to Aug. 30. Investigators say Ammel entered Sinema’s Cave Creek home while she was away, demanded she post a video to her X account, and threatened to damage the house if she did not comply.
She refused. Investigators say Ammel threw 22 pieces of artwork into her backyard pool, left another painting near the front entrance spray-painted with black lettering, and smashed expensive liquor bottles and a mirror. The art damage alone was put at $123,015. Total damage topped $200,000.
Sinema handed investigators text messages, video recordings and surveillance footage of the damage being done. Ammel was charged with one count of criminal damage, a class 4 felony. He was arrested in September after being discharged from a mental health facility, then released with an electronic ankle monitor and orders to stay away from her.
Ammel’s own account of that night
Before the second arrest, Ammel sat for an interview with The Arizona Republic and explained himself in plain terms.
“I was p—ed at the system and I took it out on her art,” he told the paper. “The American people have no idea how [expletive] up our government is and, like, what our politicians spend their time doing.”
He said he told Sinema he would toss one piece of her art into the pool every 10 minutes until she posted the video, and that he sent her videos as he went, according to a police report. He also said he deliberately spared artwork that friends had given her.
“I was trying to get her to come back home, or to do something, or to use her connections for good instead of for, to make money,” he said. “I was just going through it, and I don’t usually drink, and I got drunk, and I destroyed some of her paintings.”
“I’m not a bad guy,” he added. “I’m not crazy. I’m just really [expletive] smart, and I’ve seen behind the curtains.”
The video he wanted posted was from 2007
Ammel, a former Green Beret who struggles with brain injuries from his service, told Arizona’s Family the footage came from his 2007 deployment and appeared to show him and others giving first aid to an injured service member. He said he wanted Sinema to use her Pentagon contacts to find out why his unit never received the Presidential Unit Citation, an award for heroism.
He told the Republic he wanted her to post the clip “because she works for some of the companies that financially benefit from the genocide in Gaza and the current war we’re losing in Iran.”
He pointed to a Washington, D.C., event for Palantir CEO Alex Karp that he attended with Sinema on their last trip together, which he called a “genocide celebration.” Records show Karp and other Palantir employees donated thousands to Sinema’s campaign in 2022 and 2023, and that she returned some of the money when she decided not to seek reelection.
Ammel also said he and Sinema sometimes lived together, and that she left him alone at the house during what he described as a stress-induced breakdown.
The lawsuit that pulled all of this into the open
Ammel’s former wife, Heather Ammel, sued Sinema in North Carolina state court in September 2025, using the state’s alienation of affection law. Sinema had the case moved to federal court in January. The suit seeks more than $25,000 and alleges the affair wrecked a 14-year marriage.
The complaint accuses Sinema of pursuing Ammel while knowing he was married, trading messages with him on the encrypted app Signal, paying for psychedelic treatment for him, and hiring him as a national security fellow in her Senate office.
Sinema’s lawyers tried to get the case thrown out, arguing she has no real connection to North Carolina. U.S. District Judge David A. Bragdon rejected that in early September, pointing to nine text messages Sinema sent Ammel while he was physically in the state and calling it “implausible” that she did not know where he was. Her legal team also subpoenaed Heather Ammel’s therapy records, then withdrew the subpoena.
What Sinema said under oath
In a deposition, Sinema said she and Ammel began a sexual relationship in May 2024, while he was still married. She said they were intimate during a trip to New York for CNN anchor Jessica Dean’s wedding. She has said she first met Ammel in 2022, and the affair began over Memorial Day weekend in 2024.
The encounters continued while she was serving in the Senate. He separated from Heather and moved out of their North Carolina home in late 2024.
Court papers in the civil case trace the relationship back to December 2023, when Sinema asked Ammel to work security for a U2 concert at the Sphere in Las Vegas. His then-wife noticed the two were texting more often on Signal. The filings also describe trips to San Francisco, a Taylor Swift concert and Napa Valley, and an incident at the Innings Festival where Sinema allegedly got “handsy” with her bodyguard.
A wall is going up around the Cave Creek house
A construction worker outside Sinema’s home told Arizona’s Family that crews had spent about two weeks building a wall around the property. A neighbor, speaking off camera, said her plans to upgrade security went back to when she first moved in more than a year ago, after she received threats.
The same neighbor said he believed Ammel used to live at the house, recalling his truck parked there and Ammel doing yard work, though he said that was a while ago.
Sinema left the Democratic Party to become an independent, declined to run for reelection, and is now a senior adviser at the law and lobbying firm Hogan Lovells.
Ammel’s next court date is Oct. 15. The judge has already said he will be there whether he agrees to go or not.
